Comparing personal loans sounds straightforward until you open three tabs and realise one lender quotes weekly repayments, another includes fees in the comparison rate, and a third offers same day approval but won't say what the interest rate actually is until you apply.
The decision you're making isn't just about finding the lowest rate. It's about working out which loan structure actually suits your repayment capacity, whether the fees will cost you more than a slightly higher interest rate, and whether the lender will approve you in the first place. Most comparison sites rank loans by advertised rate, but that number often applies to borrowers with perfect credit and doesn't reflect what you'll actually pay.
Start with the comparison rate, not the advertised rate
The comparison rate bundles the interest rate and most fees into a single percentage, giving you a clearer picture of the true cost over the loan term. A personal loan with a 9% interest rate and a $400 establishment fee might have a comparison rate of 10.2%, while a loan at 9.5% with no establishment fee could sit at 9.8%. The second option costs less overall, even though the headline rate looks higher.
Comparison rates assume you'll borrow a specific amount (usually $30,000) and repay over a set term (usually five years). If you're borrowing $10,000 over two years, the comparison rate becomes less useful because establishment fees hit harder on smaller loan amounts. In that scenario, calculate the total cost yourself by adding the interest and all fees, then dividing by the loan term.
Ready to get started?
Book a chat with a Finance & Mortgage Broker at Leveled Up Finance today.
Fixed rate vs variable rate: which one suits your budget
A fixed rate personal loan locks your repayment amount for the entire loan term, which works well if you're on a tight budget and can't absorb an increase. A variable rate personal loan can move up or down, and while that introduces uncertainty, it also means you can usually make extra repayments without penalty.
Consider someone borrowing $20,000 over four years to consolidate credit card debt. If they lock in a fixed rate, they know exactly what they'll pay each fortnight, and that predictability helps them plan around other expenses. If they choose a variable rate and their income increases halfway through the term, they can pay more without triggering early exit fees. The trade-off is whether you value certainty or flexibility more.
Most fixed rate personal loans charge an early exit fee if you repay the loan before the term ends. That fee can range from $150 to several hundred dollars, depending on how much of the term remains. If there's any chance you'll receive a windfall or want to clear the debt early, a variable rate loan with no early exit fee will save you money.
Secured vs unsecured: how it changes what you pay
An unsecured personal loan doesn't require an asset as security, which makes the application process faster but pushes the interest rate higher because the lender takes on more risk. A secured personal loan uses an asset like a car as collateral, which typically drops the interest rate by one to three percentage points.
In a scenario where someone needs $15,000 for medical expenses, an unsecured personal loan might come in at 11% while a secured loan using their car as security could be 8.5%. Over a three-year term, that difference saves around $700 in interest. The downside is that if they default, the lender can repossess the car. If the asset is essential for work or family commitments, an unsecured personal loan might be worth the extra cost for the peace of mind.
Some lenders also offer secured personal loans against savings or term deposits, which can drop the rate even further without risking an asset you rely on daily.
Look at fees separately from the interest rate
Establishment fees, monthly fees, and early exit fees can add hundreds or even thousands of dollars to the cost of a personal loan, and they're easy to overlook when you're focused on the interest rate. An establishment fee typically ranges from $0 to $500, while monthly fees sit between $0 and $15. A $10 monthly fee doesn't sound significant, but over a five-year loan term it adds $600 to the total cost.
Some lenders waive the establishment fee but charge a higher monthly fee, while others do the opposite. If you're borrowing a smaller loan amount or repaying over a shorter loan term, prioritise lenders with no monthly fee. If you're borrowing a larger amount over a longer term, an establishment fee becomes less significant compared to the interest you'll pay.
Early exit fees matter if there's any chance you'll refinance or repay the loan ahead of schedule. Some lenders charge a flat fee, others calculate it based on how much of the term remains. If you're consolidating debt and expect your financial situation to improve, avoid loans with punitive exit fees.
Match the loan term to your actual repayment capacity
Stretching a personal loan over a longer term drops your fortnightly or monthly repayments, but it increases the total interest you'll pay. Shortening the term lifts the repayment amount but cuts the interest significantly. The right choice depends on whether you need breathing room in your budget or want to clear the debt as quickly as possible.
Someone borrowing $25,000 at 10% over three years would repay around $806 per month and pay $3,016 in interest. Extending that same loan to five years drops the monthly repayment to $531 but pushes the total interest to $6,860. That's an extra $3,844 in interest for the sake of $275 less per month. If your budget can handle the higher repayment, the shorter term saves you a substantial amount.
If you're not sure whether you can sustain the higher repayment, choose a variable rate loan with flexible repayment options. That way, you can start with a manageable repayment and increase it later if your income improves, without locking yourself into a fixed commitment you can't meet.
Check eligibility before you apply
Every personal loan application leaves a mark on your credit file, and multiple applications in a short period can lower your credit score and make lenders nervous. Before you apply, check the lender's eligibility criteria and make sure you meet the minimum requirements for income, employment, and credit history.
Most lenders require a minimum income of $25,000 to $35,000 per year, but some will accept lower amounts if you're employed full-time or have a guarantor. If you've had a default or missed payment in the past two years, some lenders will decline your personal loan application outright, while others specialise in lending to people with impaired credit. Applying to the wrong lender wastes time and damages your credit file unnecessarily.
If you're unsure whether you'll be approved, speak to a broker who can assess your situation and direct you to lenders that are more likely to say yes. That approach reduces the number of applications you need to submit and improves your chances of getting the loan amount and personal loan interest rate you're after. You can reach out to our team at Leveled Up Finance to discuss your options.
Repayment frequency: why it matters more than you think
Most lenders offer weekly, fortnightly, or monthly repayments, and the frequency you choose affects how much interest you'll pay over the life of the loan. Making repayments more often means you're chipping away at the principal faster, which reduces the amount of interest that accrues.
If you're paid fortnightly, aligning your loan repayments to your pay cycle makes budgeting simpler and means you'll make 26 repayments per year instead of 12 monthly payments. That extra repayment each year can shave months off your loan term and save you hundreds in interest, depending on the loan amount and rate.
Some lenders also allow you to change your repayment frequency or make extra repayments without penalty, which gives you more control if your financial situation changes. If that flexibility matters to you, confirm it before you sign the loan agreement.
Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you to talk through your personal loan options and work out which structure suits your budget and goals.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between the advertised rate and the comparison rate?
The advertised rate is just the interest rate, while the comparison rate includes most fees bundled into a single percentage. The comparison rate gives you a clearer picture of the true cost over the loan term.
Should I choose a fixed or variable rate personal loan?
A fixed rate locks your repayment amount for the entire term, which suits tight budgets. A variable rate can move up or down but usually allows extra repayments without penalty, giving you more flexibility if your income increases.
How do fees affect the total cost of a personal loan?
Establishment fees, monthly fees, and early exit fees can add hundreds or thousands to the total cost. A $10 monthly fee adds $600 over five years, so it's worth comparing fees separately from the interest rate.
Does the loan term affect how much interest I pay?
Yes, stretching the loan over a longer term reduces your repayments but increases total interest. Shortening the term lifts the repayment amount but can save you thousands in interest.
Why does repayment frequency matter?
Making repayments more often means you reduce the principal faster, which cuts the amount of interest that accrues. Fortnightly repayments result in 26 payments per year instead of 12 monthly ones, which can shave months off your loan term.
